Let’s say you’re catering a production in Los Angeles and your do-goody, hippie-dippy client wants you to “go green.” You start looking for “sustainable” serving wares. You spend a mountain of money of on agave forks & biodegradable cups. You’re feeling pretty good that your serving ware isn’t going to sit in a landfill for the next 5,000 years, its toxic leachate swill seeping into the groundwater and poisoning the land for generations untold… Then you get to set and the smug sustainability coordinator (me) drops by and tells you that none of the stuff you just dropped mad cash on is accepted in Los Angeles county and it’s all going to the landfill. You exclaim “WELL HOW ABOUT I COMPOST YOU, BUDDY???” You read Nietzche’s Götterdämmerung while drinking a goblet of blood from atop your pile of landfill-destined PLA bioplastic coffee cups and cry. “Why bother when Compostable God is dead?” You ask.
I’m going to tell you why you should still bother and dispel some common misconceptions about sustainable products you might encounter when catering a production. I draw heavily from Upstream’s Reuse Wins 2024 report (which you should absolutely read), my first-hand experiences working on set as a sustainability coordinator, and class discussions from my sustainability studies at Santa Monica College.
Short answer: you can only compost food, paper, or untreated wood in Los Angeles. No bioplastics, PLA, or compostable plastic items are processed in the county. If you must get disposables, use only wood or bamboo utensils.
Look for fiber or wood food trays, bowls, coffee cup lids, and sauce cups (for espresso and dipping). Paper napkins are compostable out of the gate. Since we can’t process PLA cups, you should purchase #1, #2, or #5 recyclable standard plastic cold cups (more on that later). About the ubiquitous red Solo cups…If someone writes a bad country song about a product, it’s almost certainly not recyclable (code #6 plastic 🤮).
Coffee cups are not recyclable or compostable in LA county—even the ones labelled “compostable.” The SoFi cup looks promising (listed as “backyard compostable / no PLA”), though I haven’t gotten confirmation from local composters and the ones in my tumbling composter haven’t had enough time to break down. Ultimately though, compostables shift environmental impacts away from landfills and into production. The only truly sustainable—and money-saving—products are reusables.
BUY THESE Quick Reference Guide
I’m linking a bunch to EcoSet here—I know from working with them that the team makes the effort to find products that can actually be composted and recycled in LA county. If you don’t want to go through them, you should look for similar products or materials on supplier sites like U-Line or the barftastic Amazon.
IT’S BACK TO HELL WITH YOU!!!
Here’s a list of greenwashed items you should avoid at all costs:
Anything bioplastic or PLA (plant-based plastic, agave plastic, potato plastic)
Any wax or plastic-coated paper or cardboard
Any straw with a liner or plastic-like material
WTF is a Bioplastic, anyway?
As stated above, a bioplastic something you’re going to send straight to “don’t buy that” hell. Why? Bioplastics are materials usually made from plants or algae that mimic the properties of petroleum-based plastics. Unlike petroleum plastics, microbes can break down bioplastics quickly…under precise conditions of high temperature industrial composting facilities that you won’t find outside of San Francisco. Unlike petroleum plastics, bioplastics are very expensive. If you throw a bioplastic utensil on the ground, it won’t break down any faster than traditional plastic. If you landfill bioplastics, they’ll release methane for centuries. If you see the words “plant-based, bio-based, or compostable” on something that looks like plastic, RUN.
Time for PROFESSOR MODE—
Greenwashing is a major problem in the “sustainable products” industry…that is, when a company markets a product claiming it to be good for the environment when it is in fact no different or worse than the traditional disposable options. The recycling symbol has a long sordid history of being coopted and neutered by the plastics industry. The terms biodegradeable (will eventually break down) compostable (will break down into water and useable nutrients in a short time) get you salivating—until you learn that just because a product is labelled compostable doesn’t mean that your city has the infrastructure to actually process the materials…most cities in the United States outside of the Bay Area do not have much capacity for composting. These terms, like recyclable, are poorly regulated. Just because a product says it’s recyclable or compostable does not mean your city can actually compost it.
How do you know what your city accepts?
Waste processing varies from city to city and even between different neighborhoods of the same city! The city of Los Angeles has 10 different waste contractors, each with different rules. I mostly work with Athens Services on productions. They have a handy What Goes Where guide I reference religiously while sorting. Other waste services have similar guides (LASAN, Republic, NASA, Waste Management). You may have to do extra digging if your city manages its own waste. Santa Monica (where I live) sends landfill to Sun Valley, recycling to Culver City, and compost to Athens (source: a classmate who works for SM’s recycling program).
Are compostables actually better for the environment?
Short answer: no. According to Upstream’s report (pg. 34), compostable disposables shift the environmental impact away from landfills and into production. Compostable plastics require large energy, water, and chemical inputs to make the materials. Most of these products are not composted, however. A metal fork has a net environmental benefit after two washes that increases with each wash. Reusable cups, plates, and clamshells are have significantly lower associated costs. Food for thought: commercially compostable items have to be sorted, trucked to a processing facility, composted, then trucked back out to users—all of which has associated environmental costs.
About Reusables…
According to Upstream’s report (p.59), a 20-year Starbucks study found that a typical cafe could save $6000 per year with 10 reusable cups used per hour. A study by CIRAIG for Recyc-Quebec found that ceramic mugs save money once they are used 45 times (a month and a half of regular use’ish). Between 2017-19, a Rethink Disposable program got 80 restaurants to compete for a zero-waste certification and in the process eliminated 6 million’ish disposable foodware items, eliminated 32 tons of waste, and saved $140,000’ish per year. All of the studies in the Reuse Wins report did not find any significant labor cost increases.
That’s great and all, but how could this play out on a chaotic film set? Departments are set in their ways, we’re all running on zero sleep, and working under ridiculous constant time crunches.
From the sustainability department-side, we sometimes manage reusables ourselves. We’ll bring cups, plates, and utensils ourselves (love those kit fees, right?) We sometimes work with reusable vendors to manage the washing and supply of foodware (Buoy, R-Cup, Upstream’s Wash Hub Directory), sometimes we manage this in-house. If catering washes dishes on site, I will often ask if they need an extra hand to help with washing, especially if we bring extra reusables ourselves. This can be a sign of good faith to the caterers—because sustainability loves to throw curve balls at catering 🤣) As a person who spends disgusting amounts of hours sorting trash, I would much rather spend that time washing cups. I’ve been looking into a portable dishwasher for smaller jobs as well.
From the catering perspective, I’ve heard caterers ask for an extra hand to help with dishwashing when production wants to implement reusables. This might be the commie in me, but I feel like a person’s wage is a much better investment than throw away utensils. All told, it’s still likely cheaper than tossing piles of single-use utensils into the void. Ultimately though, sustainability is a marathon. We should implement what makes sense for our circumstances right now and not let perfect be the enemy of progress. Small sustainable changes add up over time!
You may also want to look into getting TRUE Zero Waste certified. The process is lengthy, but the goal is to reduce your waste and save lots of money on operating expenses. I haven’t seen too much of TRUE on the ground in productions, but I believe this is a golden opportunity to be an early adopter. Regardless, TRUE has lots of resources available to help cut back on your waste, both material and financial.
Film sets are always a dance, a negotiation to see how you can appease the boss, get the job done, and still turn a profit. Sustainability adds a new set of challenges, but the longterm rewards are staggering. We all want to keep working in this unique industry and still have planet to call home.
Sources
Upstream’s Reuse Wins 2024 Report
Yale Environment 360 “Why Bioplastics Will Not Solve the World’s Plastics Problem”
Yale Climate Connections “How the Recycling Symbol Lost Its Meaning”
EU Policy Framework on Biodegrable & Compostable Plastics
US Composting Council “STA Certified Participants”
Athen’s Services “What Goes Where Guide”
LA Dept of Sanitation and Environment Recycling Guide
Upstream’s Wash Hub Map
TRUE Zero Waste